Fractions in Disguise Class 8: 8 Percentage Mistakes That Change the Answer
← Education, Skills & PolicyA learner can remember a percentage formula and still get the answer wrong because the base changed. In Fractions in Disguise, the same % sign can act on an original value, cost price, marked price or an amount that has already changed.
This page is for that problem. It does not reproduce the NCERT exercise solutions. It shows the reasoning errors that make percentage answers fail, then gives a changed question to test whether the idea transfers.
Start with one question: percentage of what?
Before calculating, name the quantity being treated as 100%. The formula is usually the easy part; choosing the right reference quantity is what makes the calculation meaningful.
Base = original amount
In standard chapter questions: base = cost price
Base = marked price
Base = taxable price at that step
Dividing percentage change by the new amount
Wrong approach: A price rises from ₹800 to ₹920, so the increase is ₹120. The learner calculates 120 ÷ 920 × 100.
Why it breaks: Percentage change compares the change with where you started, not where you ended.
Use the original amount as the base: 120 ÷ 800 × 100 = 15%.
Changed check: ₹500 becomes ₹575. Percentage increase? 15%
Confusing “165% of” with “increased by 165%”
Wrong idea: “The new value is 165% of the old value” is treated as a 165% increase.
Why it breaks: The original value already represents 100%.
165% of the original means 100% + 65%. The increase is 65%, not 165%.
Changed check: A quantity becomes 140% of its earlier value. Increase? 40%
Using selling price as the base for an ordinary profit-percentage question
Wrong approach: A shopkeeper buys for ₹800 and sells for ₹960. Profit is ₹160, then the learner calculates 160 ÷ 960 × 100.
Why it breaks: In the standard profit-percentage questions used in this chapter, the comparison is with what was invested: the cost price. A differently worded question can deliberately choose another base, so the wording still matters.
Profit % = 160 ÷ 800 × 100 = 20%.
Changed check: CP ₹600, SP ₹690. Profit percentage on cost? 15%
Taking discount from the wrong price
Wrong approach: A discount is applied to whichever price was last calculated, even when the question states that the discount is on marked price.
Why it breaks: A percentage has no meaning until its base is named.
For marked price ₹2,000 with 25% off: discount = ₹500, so selling price = ₹1,500.
Changed check: Marked price ₹1,600, 15% discount. Selling price? ₹1,360
Adding successive discounts
Wrong answer: 30% off followed by another 20% off is called a 50% discount.
Why it breaks: The second discount acts on the already-reduced price, so its base is smaller.
₹1,000 → 30% off gives ₹700 → 20% off gives ₹560. The total reduction is ₹440, or 44%, not 50%.
Changed check: 20% off, then 10% off. Overall discount? 28%
Netting a discount and GST as if both percentages share one base
Wrong answer: “20% discount and 10% GST means 10% off overall.”
Why it breaks: GST is calculated after the discount, so the second percentage acts on a different amount.
On ₹1,000: 20% discount gives ₹800; 10% GST on ₹800 is ₹80; final price = ₹880.
Changed check: ₹2,000 with 25% discount, then 12% tax. Final price? ₹1,680
Assuming equal percentage increase and decrease cancel
Wrong idea: “Up 20%, then down 20%, so we return to the start.”
Why it breaks: The decrease acts on the larger, updated amount.
Start at 100. Increase 20% → 120. Decrease 20% of 120 → 96. Net result = 4% below the start.
Changed check: Up 10%, then down 10%. Final value from 100? 99
Mixing percentage points with relative percentage change
Wrong statement: A rate moves from 20% to 25%, so it “increased by 5%.”
Why it breaks: The direct difference is 5 percentage points. Relative percentage change compares that 5-point rise with the original 20%.
Percentage-point rise = 25 − 20 = 5 points. Relative increase = 5 ÷ 20 × 100 = 25%.
Changed check: A rate rises from 40% to 50%. Point rise? Relative increase? 10 points; 25%
₹1,000
marked price
₹800
new base
₹880
final price
One more trap: reverse percentage is not “undo by the same subtraction”
If ₹800 is the price after a 20% discount, ₹800 is 80% of the original. The original is therefore ₹800 ÷ 0.8 = ₹1,000. Adding 20% of ₹800 would give ₹960 because it uses the wrong base.
Changed check: After a 25% increase, a value is 500. Original value? 500 ÷ 1.25 = 400
Use a wrong answer as a clue, not just a mark
A repeated wrong answer often tells you which decision broke. Three quick fingerprints:
The learner probably divided the ₹120 change by the new ₹920 amount. Route back to the original base before doing more percentage-change questions.
The learner is probably netting two percentages that act on different bases. Route back to the amount after each step.
The learner may be mixing a 12-percentage-point rise with relative percentage change. Route back to what is being compared with the original 60%.
This is the same principle behind Dishantra’s Error Check: use the pattern of an error to choose the smallest useful repair, then test a changed question.
A compact decision rule
Before doing any Class 8 percentage calculation, write three short prompts:
Name the base in words: original price, cost price, marked price, discounted price, total, principal or another whole.
If the amount changes before the next percentage is applied, assume the base may have changed too.
Amount, percentage, percentage points, profit on cost, discount from marked price and final price after tax are not interchangeable.
Three transfer checks
These deliberately change the surface details. Try them without looking back.
Check 1: A price falls from ₹1,200 to ₹1,020. What is the percentage decrease?
Decrease = ₹180. Base = original ₹1,200. So 180 ÷ 1,200 × 100 = 15%.
Check 2: An item gets 10% off and then another 10% off. Is the overall discount 20%?
No. ₹100 becomes ₹90, then ₹81. Overall discount = 19%.
Check 3: A pass rate rises from 60% to 72%. What is the percentage-point rise and relative percentage increase?
Rise = 12 percentage points. Relative increase = 12 ÷ 60 × 100 = 20%.
Sources & curriculum reference
Primary curriculum reference: National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT), Grade 8 Ganita Prakash, Part II, Fractions in Disguise (current 2026–27 edition; consulted through the NCERT Online Textbooks service).
All worked examples, changed checks and diagrams on this page are independently created by Dishantra. This page does not reproduce NCERT exercise text and is not affiliated with or endorsed by NCERT, CBSE or any school.
Visual sources: both instructional graphics are original Dishantra diagrams; no external image assets are used.
Editorial note
Curriculum coverage and the current search landscape were reviewed on 27 October 2026. Search results were used to identify saturated solution-bank formats and to keep this guide problem-led; competitor wording, exercise text and solution paths were not copied.
Prepared with AI-assisted research and writing, then independently rechecked for mathematical correctness, wording assumptions and changed-context transfer under Dishantra’s educational semantic-QA standard. Dishantra editorial standards
